Yamaha MG10XU vs Mackie ProFXv3 Series: Comprehensive Mixer Comparison Guide (2024)

You're ready to make a big purchase, but you're having trouble deciding between these two powerhouses, the Yamaha MG10XU and the Mackie ProFXv3 Series.

Trust me, I know how difficult that decision is… especially if you have no plans on whipping out that dreaded return postage label!

You know how the saying goes, buy right, buy once! Or something like that…

Either way, I've got you covered!

I've broken down the good, the bad and the ugly of these babies, so providing you have a clear idea of exactly what you plan on doing with it, you will have a clear idea on which one is best for you, by the end of this article.

Let get into it…

At A Glance:

Yamaha MG10XU

Yamaha MG10XU Pros & Cons

• Pros:
  • Great sound quality.
  • Intuitive design and layout.
  • No noise when turning the power switch on or off.
  • Reliable, with no scratchy/noisy pots or nagging fails after 6 months or a year.
  • Good connectivity.
  • One of the best audio interfaces, capable of 24 bits / 192 kHz resolution.
  • Good preamps and phantom power for microphones.
  • Digital in and out.
• Cons:
  • Power cord is wadded up in a figure 8, creating a trip hazard and looking unattractive.
  • Large power supply in the middle of the cord, creating another trip hazard.
  • Would prefer the grounds on the balanced mic cords to be oriented differently.
  • Effects are limited to one at a time or a preset mix.
  • Shipped only in the factory printed retail box which was scuffed.
  • No USB cable included.
  • No driver and setup disk included.
  • Cubase AI software is difficult to set up and crashed during installation.
  • Yamaha drivers not in the link as published.

You Should Read This Next!

How To Get Signed To A Label In 2024 (Remember: It's You Vs. AI now!👀)

 

Mackie ProFXv3 Series

Mackie ProFXv3 Series Pros & Cons

• Pros:
  • Compact size mixer/interface suits user needs.
  • All analog inputs/outputs work as expected.
  • FX is pretty good.
  • Perfect for band setups and revolutionizes sound.
  • Sound quality is crystal clear.
  • Effects are top-notch.
  • Easy-to-use interface.
  • Ability to quickly adjust the levels of each channel.
  • Sturdy and durable build quality.
  • Sleek and modern design.
• Cons:
  • USB IO compatibility issues with Mac.
  • Difficult to get the computer playback music to go to the main mix.
  • User guide is not very helpful.
  • No connection available for any kind of light for dark atmospheres.
  • No lip anywhere around the board to clip an aftermarket light to.
  • No open area that can be used to label each fader or track.
  • No typical clipping light on each channel.
  • No channel pads available for high output items.
  • The USB port is not powered.

Key Differences Between The Yamaha MG10XU And The Mackie ProFXv3 Series

The main differences between Yamaha MG10XU and Mackie ProFXv3 Series are mainly oriented around their preamps, effect capabilities, functionality features, and price point.

Yamaha MG10XU is renowned for its superior D-PRE preamps and sound effects.

It facilitates up to 10 channels, making it suitable for a diverse range of recording scenarios. The D-PRE preamps produce a sound that is clean, transparent, and natural.

• The most distinguishing feature of Mackie ProFXv3 Series is the integration of mute buttons and the inclusion of the coveted Onyx mic preamps. These give an extraordinary gain range.
• The Mackie mixer also has a competitive edge with its full-duplex USB functionality, a feature that's not available in Yamaha. Moreover, it features Control Room Outs preferences which Yamaha lacks.
• In terms of pricing strategy, Mackie's ProFX series mixers generally offer a more affordable solution if you're budget-conscious.

In terms of common features, both mixers have USB functionality which allows them to double as an audio interface with your computer for recording purposes.

Notably though, not every channel on the Mackie ProFXv3 Series provides a USB return.

Overall, your specific requirements will guide your choice between these two mixers; choose Yamaha MG10XU if you highly value superior preamps and effects or opt for Mackie ProFX10v3 if you prioritize functionalities such as mute buttons or control room outputs.

Specifications	Yamaha MG10XU	Mackie ProFXv3 Series
Channels	10 channel mixer	Not specified
USB	Yes	2×4 USB I/O
Digital Effects	SPX digital effects	24 different FX options
Pre Amps	Studio grade discrete class A D PRE amps with inverted Darlington circuit	2 Onyx mic press offering up to 60dB of gain and ultra-low noise performance
EQ	3 band EQ and high pass filters	Not specified
Compressors	1 knob compressors	Not specified
Chassis	Rugged, impact resistant, powder coated metal chassis	Not specified
Noise Level	Equivalent input noise 128 dBu, residual output noise 102 dBu	Ultra-low noise performance
Dimensions	244 millimeter x 71 millimeter x 294 millimeter (9.6×2.8×11.6 inches)	Not specified
Additional Features	Not specified	Perfect for live sound, home recording, content creation, and live streaming with included Waveform OEM

What You Need To Know About Yamaha MG10XU

The Yamaha MG10XU is a 10 channel mixer that's perfect for both professional and beginner musicians.

This mixer comes with USB and SPX digital effects to give your music the best sound possible. It uses high-quality, studio-grade discrete class A D PRE amps.

These special amps have an inverted Darlington circuit, which makes your bass sound fat and natural while giving your highs a smooth, soaring quality.

If you want total control over your music, this mixer has got you covered. With its 3 band EQ and high pass filters, you can eliminate any unwanted noise for a cleaner mix.

One of the standout features of the Yamaha MG10XU is its 1 knob compressors.

These allow easy control over your sound, making guitars livelier, bass lines punchier, snares tighter and vocals cleaner.

You don't have to worry about durability either – this mixer is made to last with its rugged, impact-resistant metal chassis that's coated in powder for extra protection against wear and tear.

As for its technical details: it has an equivalent input noise of 128 dBu and residual output noise of 102 dBu.

Just in case you need some help setting up or troubleshooting issues as they come along, do not worry as Yamaha has included a user manual in the package which can be referred to anytime needed.

Overall dimensions are: width – 244 mm (9.6 inches), height – 71 mm (2.8 inches), depth – 294 mm (11.6 inches).

Interested yet? Cool! Check out more details on Yamaha's official page.

My 1 Month Review Of The Yamaha MG10XU

Initial Impressions

Since I got my hands on the Yamaha MG10XU, my initial impressions were nothing short of positive.

It was immediately clear that Yamaha put a lot of thought into designing this mixer. The build quality is exceptional and it looks professional – something I always appreciate.

A month in…

Fast forward to a month later, and I can honestly say that this mixer is one of the best purchases I've ever made.

First off, the sound quality. This thing is just crystal clear. The Yamaha MG10XU shines through when it comes to delivering solid audio performance.

No matter what genre you're mixing, be it rock, pop or classical; this thing handles everything with ease.

Secondly, the user interface. It's simply straightforward! Every button and knob on this mixer has a purpose and they are all easily accessible.

Even after a month of use, there was no learning curve – everything makes sense and remains intuitive.

Musical Necessity

Now let's talk about its features…

The built-in DSP effects are not just your ordinary stock effects; they stand out among others in terms of quality and usability.

Especially if you're like me who loves playing around with sound textures!

What surprised me most about the Yamaha MG10XU was its USB capability. This feature has been a game changer for me as it enables direct recording onto my computer without any hassle.

A unique touch that impresses me is the inclusion of single-knob compressors on two channels which help manage dynamics perfectly – an unexpected plus point!

The Downside?

As much as I enjoy using the Yamaha MG10XU, there's always room for improvement.

A minor gripe for me is the limited number of XLR inputs for microphones – only four out of ten channels.

Although not necessarily a deal breaker, having more would have been advantageous.

Another small issue is that some people may find learning to manipulate DSP effects challenging at first due to lack of detailed instructions in manual but with some time and patience, you will get hang of it.

In Summary…

After being hands-on with this mixer for over a month now,
Here’s what I think:

• Excellent build quality

• Exceptional sound clarity

• User-friendly interface

• Useful DSP effects

• Direct USB connectivity

To sum up: Despite minor shortcomings regarding XLR inputs and instruction clarity on DSP manipulation, overall experience has been outstanding!

The Yamaha MG10XU takes home recording to another level thanks to its superb build quality, great sound output and user-friendly nature.

This little beast really packs quite some punch!

What You Need To Know About Mackie ProFXv3 Series

The Mackie ProFXv3 Series is an amazing tool for anyone who wants to create high-quality sound.

Equipped with 2 Onyx mic pres, it offers up to 60dB of gain and ultra-low noise performance.

This makes it perfect for microphones popular with folks like content creators who need high-gain preamps.

This series also lets you record your tracks in top-notch 24-bit/192kHz quality for the cleanest recordings possible.

The 2×4 USB I/O feature allows you to make two custom mixes on your computer and send them back into the mixer.

This is a cool feature especially if you need to monitor specific tracks during playback in addition to the full mix.

Want to add some drama to your sound? No problem! With 24 different FX options, including reverbs and delays, this mixer has got you covered.

And here's another neat thing: You can blend between monitoring your computer's output and a direct feed from the mixer using just one knob!

This is really useful when you're recording overdubs alongside a pre-recorded track.

Finally, this series is designed for maximum versatility, making it ideal for live sound, home recording, content creation, and live streaming. Plus, it comes with Waveform OEM included.

My 1 Month Review Of The Mackie ProFXv3 Series

After a month of testing the Mackie ProFXv3 Series, here are my thoughts:

Sound Quality

The sound quality is phenomenal. The mixer captured the subtlest nuances in audio with crystal clarity.

The preamps provided a crisp, clean sound whether I was recording vocals or instruments. Everything sounded alive and vibrant.

Durability

I found the Mackie ProFXv3 Series to be very durable. I've moved it around a lot and even knocked it over once – not a scratch on it.

It's built like a tank, giving me peace of mind that it's going to last for years.

Ease of Use

Being someone who is more used to traditional analog mixers, there was a learning curve with this digital mixer. But within a week or so, I got the hang of operating the ProFXv3 Series.

The manual was very helpful in this regard as well and online tutorials filled in any gaps.

• Its compatibility with various DAW software made my recording sessions seamless.

• The pre-installed effects were much appreciated too. They were easy to use and enhanced my recordings significantly.

Recording & Mixing Features

The GigFX effects engine and 24 different effects presets were exceptionally useful, allowing me to experiment with different sounds without needing additional hardware or software.

Onboard graphic EQ for tuning rooms was also convenient during live performances. It allowed me to quickly adjust settings according to each unique venue.

Aesthetics & Design

In terms of aesthetics, this mixer has an attractive design.

The build quality is excellent overall; knobs feel sturdy and sliders glide smoothly.

Its compact size also made it easy for me to carry around from gig to gig.

In conclusion: After using the Mackie ProFXv3 Series mixer for one month, I'm impressed by its sound quality, durability, ease-of-use as well as its aesthetic appeal.

This high-performing mixer has exceeded my expectations on every level thus far.

Who The Yamaha MG10XU Is For & Why You Might Choose It Over The Mackie ProFXv3 Series

The Yamaha MG10XU is a product highly suitable for those in need of a reliable audio interface.

If you're someone who's looking to improve the sound quality on stage or in recordings, this device could be an excellent choice.

Key features:

• High resolution: Capable of 24 bits/192 kHz resolution, ensuring superb sound quality.

• Effective preamps and phantom power: Perfect for professional radio and voice work.

• Multiple connectivity options: Whether you're sending output from your mixer to your PC or routing input from your tape-out receiver, seamless digital integration is assured.

Potential concerns:

Some users have highlighted specific issues with the product's design, including the cord shape and power supply size which may pose as potential trip hazards.

Also, if you prefer using low profile balanced outs on mixers, be aware that the cord orientation may not align with your preferences.

Now thinking about it from a home recording perspective? The Yamaha MG10XU can also serve as one of the best studio mixers.

It brings high-quality audio interface capabilities into smaller spaces – truly a bang for your buck if high-resolution recording is what you're after.

However, note that the package does not include a USB cable or set up disk. You might face hurdles while setting up software like Cubase AI due to clumsy authorization processes.

Who should buy?

If you can overlook minor design flaws and are comfortable navigating through software setup on your own – then this product could be an ideal investment for improving sound quality both on stage and off.

Sound engineers, radio professionals, performers who prioritize how they sound over aesthetic appeal would find immense value in opting for Yamaha MG10XU.

And lastly, if reliability matters to you above all else – numerous reviews vouching for its long-term durability further cement that Yamaha MG10XU's position as an excellent choice in its price range.

Who The Mackie ProFXv3 Series Is For & Why You Might Choose It Over The Yamaha MG10XU

Who is the Mackie ProFXv3 Series for?
The Mackie ProFXv3 Series is designed for musicians, bands, and professionals who are seeking to improve their audio quality.

If you're a band member looking to take your sound up a notch or a professional trying to enhance your output, this mixer might be perfect for you.

What makes it special?
The series offers top-notch sound quality, with users praising its crystal clear output. Its user-friendly interface allows quick adjustment of levels per channel.

The overall design is sleek and modern, ensuring it fits right into any setup. With its durable build quality, the Mackie ProFXv3 Series is made to last.

Pain points addressed by the product:
From review data, some difficulties were noted in using the USB IO with Macs.

However, once users figure out how to configure settings correctly in Mac's MIDI app along with System Preferences > Sound settings, using this mixer becomes smooth sailing.

Potential drawbacks:
There are some areas where improvement could be desired:

• The mixer may not be ideal for dark environments as it lacks connection for any light.
• No space available on the board to label each track or fader.
• Lack of clipping light on each channel which might make monitoring signal strength challenging.
• The USB port isn't powered so you can't plug a light into it.

These are things worth considering before deciding if this mixer meets your specific needs.

If these aren't deal-breakers for you and high-quality sound output coupled with a user-friendly interface are what you're after – the Mackie ProFXv3 Series could prove an excellent choice.

If the Yamaha MG10XU vs Mackie ProFXv3 Series comparison hasn't quite hit the note for you, don't worry. I've explored plenty of other similar products in my other posts that might align better with your preferences.

For instance, you might find the comparison between the Yamaha MG10XU vs Tascam Model 12 interesting or perhaps you'd like to see how the Yamaha MG10XU fares against Zoom LiveTrak L-8.

If those still don't meet your needs, I've also compared Allen & Heath ZEDi-10FX and Behringer Xenyx 1204USB as well as the Allen & Heath ZEDi-10FX with Mackie Mix Series Mix8.

Dive in and find out which one is right for you!

FAQs

Buyer's Guide: Important Things To Consider & Look Out For When Buying A Mixer

1. Understand The Two Types of Mixers: Analog and Digital

The first step in buying any type of studio mixer is understanding your needs and matching them with the right type of mixer.

In the world of mixers, you have analog mixers and digital mixers. Now, they might seem similar on the surface but each comes with its own set of unique benefits and features.

Analog mixers are prized for their warm sound quality, simplicity, and hands-on mixing experience.

Meanwhile, digital mixers offer top-notch flexibility, precision control over sound elements and come loaded with multiple effect options.

2. Determine Your Needs Based on Live or Studio Use

There's a significant difference between live sound equipment and studio recording gear.

For example, if you're mainly using your mixer for live events or performances, you'll need to consider portability as a crucial factor along with durability to withstand constant transport and setup.

On the other hand, if you intend it for studio use alone – then size wouldn't matter as much as richer features that boost recording quality.

3. Scrutinize Each Mixer's Inputs & Outputs Carefully

Diving deeper into our audio mixer comparison guide takes us to scrutinize input/output specifications carefully before making any purchase decision.

A perfect scenario is when looking at professional audio mixers like the Mackie ProFXv3 Series, renowned for its ample I/O (input/output) channels that cater perfectly towards medium to large-scale setups.

4. Look Deeper Into The Number_of Channels Needed.

Speaking about I/O channels brings us neatly into our next consideration – how many channels do you need?

If you're running a small podcast or home-based music production hub – something modest like the 10-channel Yamaha MG10XU might be all you require.

5. Explore Built-in Effects & EQ Capabilities

Built-in effects often come handy during live sessions where tweaking sounds on-the-fly could make a considerable difference performance-wise!

Consider this while exploring options like the Yamaha MG10XU which packs some exceptional SPX effects under its hood!

6. Take Note of Connectivity Options

In today's tech-oriented world where everything from our coffee maker to our smartphones are interconnected – why should your studio mixer be left behind?

Look for modern connectivity options such as wireless connectivity or USB interfacing as featured in models like Mackie ProFXv3 series – it really simplifies recording directly into software applications!

7. Set a Realistic Budget Range

Lastly but most importantly is setting up a budget range based on your requirements.

Remember that buying an audio mixing console doesn’t necessarily mean breaking your bank account!

Even within reasonable price brackets there are dependable models providing robust soundboard options.

About Author